AGM vs lithium batteries in floor scrubbers: which should you choose?

Short answer

Choose AGM if your scrubber's daily scrubbing fits in one charge and it charges fully overnight. Choose lithium if it needs top-ups during the day to keep going, and you can pay more up front. On FactoryCat machines, lithium is offered only on the four rider scrubbers, at up to 160 Ah (Pilot) or 240 Ah (GTX, GTR and XR); walk-behinds take WET (flooded) or AGM.

What batteries do FactoryCat floor scrubbers use?

Every FactoryCat walk-behind and rider scrubber comes with WET batteries as standard. WET means flooded lead-acid, with liquid inside that you top up with water. AGM is also lead-acid, but sealed. It is an option on every FactoryCat scrubber.

Lithium, which FactoryCat lists as Li-ion, is offered on the riders only: the Pilot, GTX, GTR and XR. The four walk-behinds and the Rebel stand-on take WET or AGM.

Amp-hours (Ah) measure how much charge a battery holds. Walk-behinds run at 24 volts. Their standard WET batteries go from 130 Ah on the MicroMini and Micro-HD to 310 Ah on the Mag-HD. Their AGM options go from 115 Ah to 335 Ah.

Riders run at 36 volts. The Pilot comes with 130 Ah WET, with 150 Ah WET, 150 Ah AGM or up to 160 Ah lithium as options. The GTX comes with 210 Ah WET, with 360 Ah WET, 335 Ah AGM or up to 240 Ah lithium.

The GTR comes with 310 Ah WET, with 360 Ah WET, 310 Ah AGM or up to 240 Ah lithium. The XR comes with 325 Ah WET, with 420 Ah WET, 400 Ah AGM or up to 240 Ah lithium. You will find lithium in the spec table of FactoryCat's rider brochure, on its downloads page.

How much care does each battery need?

WET batteries need regular watering. Someone has to check the cells and top them up, as the battery maker says. They also give off gas while charging, so they need a charging spot with good airflow.

AGM and lithium batteries are sealed. There is nothing to water and no open cells to overflow. On the Micro-HD, Mini-HD and Mag-HD, FactoryCat lists its AGM option as "Maintenance Free Batteries".

FactoryCat's spec tables also say the AGM option includes an onboard charger on every walk-behind and on the GTX, GTR and XR. The charger is built into the machine, so there is no separate unit to keep track of.

Lithium needs a charger made for lithium. Do not assume a lead-acid charger will work. Ask your dealer which charger to use with the lithium pack.

How does your shift pattern decide between AGM and lithium?

Lead-acid batteries, WET and AGM alike, last longest when they get one long, unbroken charge after each use. Many short top-ups shorten their life, and so does running them flat. That fits a one-shift day well: clean, plug in, and charge overnight.

Lithium is different. It generally charges faster, and it takes partial charges without that harm. So you can top it up over a lunch break or between jobs. This is called opportunity charging.

So count scrubbing hours, not shifts. Add up the hours the machine really scrubs in a day. Two shifts that each scrub for 2 hours add up to 4 hours, inside the GTX's published run time of up to 4.5 hours. FactoryCat does not say which battery that figure assumes, so ask for the run time with the battery you choose. If it covers your hours, one overnight charge does the job, and lead-acid is enough. Treat any run time as a best case.

If your hours do not fit, you need to charge during the day, and that is where lithium pays off. FactoryCat publishes no charge time for any battery, so ask your dealer what a top-up adds before you count on it.

Does lithium give you a longer run time?

No published figure says so. FactoryCat gives one run time per model, not one per battery: up to 4 hours on the Pilot, 4.5 on the GTX, and 5 on the GTR and XR. The Mag-HD walk-behind runs up to 5 hours. FactoryCat does not say which battery those figures assume.

Don't compare amp-hours across battery types. On the GTX, GTR and XR, the lithium option is up to 240 Ah, while the AGM options are 335, 310 and 400 Ah. On the Pilot it is the other way round: lithium is up to 160 Ah, against 150 Ah for the AGM and WET options. Lead-acid lasts longest when it is not run flat, so part of its rated charge goes unused in daily work. Lithium can use more of its rating.

Lithium also holds its voltage more evenly as it drains. With lead-acid, voltage falls as the charge runs down, so motors can slow a little late in the run. Lithium's clearest gain is a longer working day, because you can top it up on breaks.

How do weight, cold and wash-down change the choice?

Batteries are a big part of a scrubber's weight. The Mag-HD walk-behind weighs 441 to 481 lbs without batteries and 775 to 825 lbs with its standard batteries. So the batteries alone weigh roughly 300 to 385 lbs, more than a third of the machine.

The Pilot rider weighs 450 lbs without batteries and 550 to 750 lbs with them. Lithium is lighter than lead-acid for the same stored energy, but FactoryCat does not publish the weight of its lithium packs. Ask for the machine weight with the pack you choose.

Cold cuts what any battery can give. Lead-acid run time drops in freezers and unheated buildings. Lithium has its own limit: most packs should not be charged below freezing unless they are heated. Check the battery maker's temperature limits, and charge in a warm area where you can.

In wash-down areas, a sealed battery helps. It has no filler caps for spray to get into. On the Micro-HD, Mini-HD and Mag-HD, FactoryCat lists its AGM option with a "Spill Proof Housing". Whatever you choose, keep water out of the battery compartment and the charger.

When is AGM still the right buy?

Often. If the machine's daily scrubbing fits in one charge and it charges fully overnight, AGM does the job with no watering. It usually costs less to buy than lithium, and quick top-ups add little when the machine sits idle all night anyway.

On FactoryCat walk-behinds and the Rebel stand-on, AGM is the only sealed choice. Pick it unless someone will water WET batteries on schedule. WET is still a fair buy when the budget is tight and there is an airy place to charge. It is FactoryCat's standard battery and usually the cheapest to buy.

Lithium's case is total cost over time, not price. It usually costs the most up front. It can cost less over its life, because it is generally rated for more charge cycles and, unlike WET, needs no watering. That is a general pattern, not a FactoryCat figure.

FactoryCat publishes no price, cycle life or cost per hour for any battery. So before you buy, get four answers in writing for each battery on offer: the run time on your machine, the full-charge time, the rated cycle life and the price. With those, you can compare the cost per year of use.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Battery typeAGMLithiumWET (flooded)
On FactoryCat machinesOption on every scrubberOption on Pilot, GTX, GTR, XR onlyStandard on walk-behinds and riders
Sizes offered115–400 AhUp to 160 or 240 Ah130–420 Ah
WateringNone; sealedNone; sealedRegular topping up
Charging patternFull charge after each useTop-ups on breaks are fineFull charge after each use
Charge timeNot publishedNot publishedNot published
Cycle lifeNot publishedNot publishedNot published
Cold and wash-downSealed; less run time in coldSealed; some run-time loss; check cold-charging limitsFiller caps; less run time in cold
WeightHeavy (lead-acid)Lighter for the same energyHeavy (lead-acid)
Up-front vs total cost (general)Usually more than WET; no wateringUsually highest up front; can cost less over its lifeUsually lowest up front; needs watering time

Mag-HD v2.2

For large areas not big enough for a ride-on floor scrubber, but where maximum output is required from an industrial grade walk behind floor scrubber, the Mag-HD v2 is the clear winner. Offering exceptional run time that allows you to scrub a long time on a single charge. Multiple scrub deck options generate high operator productivity. Include an optional Spray Jet spray wand to increase the cleaning capabilities beyond that of a typical scrubber. Available in 28”(71cm) - 34”(86cm) scrub width.

Pilot v3

Ultra-maneuverable, this micro rider affords you the efficient cleaning of an industrial ride-on floor scrubber with a footprint smaller than many large walk-behind auto scrubbers. Able to navigate tight isles, narrow doorways, and smaller elevators this ride-on auto scrubber is best in class. Available in 25”(64cm) - 28”(71cm) scrub width.

GTX v2.2

Navigation of your facility is easy with this compact ride on auto scrubber. Say, “so long” to the fatigued operator from walking behind a traditional auto scrubber. With this industrial ride on floor scrubber your staff will clean more square footage during their shift and still have the time and energy to do additional work. With impressive down pressure and brush speed this machine cleans your toughest dirt. Available in 26”(68cm) - 33”(84cm) scrub width.

XR v2.0

The XR v2 battery powered industrial ride-on floor scrubber is made in America for large tough cleaning jobs. Large enough to be a warehouse floor scrubber, yet extremely maneuverable in narrow aisles. A 34 to 46 inch ride on floor scrubber that is simple to operate and not intimidating to the operator. Impressive operator visibility and comfort set us apart from the competition. Large capacity tanks and dual vacuums allow this ride on floor scrubber to finish the job fast!
Divide your cleanable floor area by the hours you have, then pick a machine whose practical rate beats that figure. FactoryCat walk-behinds have practical rates of up to 7,308 to 15,784 sq ft per hour and FactoryCat riders up to 18,000 to 29,374, based on ISSA 2010 cleaning times. A faster machine finishes sooner, but it has to fit your narrowest doorway and last the job on one charge.
Choose a rider for a large, open floor you want cleaned in fewer operator hours. Choose a walk-behind for smaller areas, crowded aisles and rooms you clean one at a time. Every FactoryCat rider covers more floor per hour than any FactoryCat walk-behind: up to 18,000 to 29,374 sq ft per hour against up to 7,308 to 15,784 (practical rates, ISSA 2010 cleaning times).
A stand-on scrubber is the middle ground: the operator rides standing, so it usually travels faster than a walk-behind and is quicker to step off than a seated rider. FactoryCat's stand-on, the Rebel, cleans a 20-inch path, the same as the 20-inch option on its smallest walk-behinds. Pick it for stop-and-go work in busy aisles, a walk-behind for small rooms, and a rider for big open floors.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I get lithium batteries on a FactoryCat walk-behind?

No. FactoryCat lists lithium only on the Pilot, GTX, GTR and XR riders. Its walk-behinds and the Rebel stand-on take WET or AGM.

How long does a floor scrubber battery take to charge?

FactoryCat publishes no charge time for any battery. It depends on the battery's size, the charger and how empty the battery is. Ask your dealer for the full-charge time on the pack you choose and, for lithium, what a top-up on a break adds.

How many charge cycles does a scrubber battery last?

FactoryCat publishes no cycle life for WET, AGM or lithium. Lithium is generally rated for more cycles than lead-acid. Real life also depends on how you charge, how far you run the battery down, and heat.

Is a battery with more amp-hours always better?

Within one battery type, more amp-hours means more stored charge, so usually a longer run. The Mag-HD, for example, comes with 310 Ah WET batteries, and a 360 Ah WET option is offered. Across battery types, the numbers do not compare one to one, so ask for the run time with each option.