Disk vs cylindrical vs orbital floor scrubber: which scrub deck do you need?

Short answer

Pick a disk deck for wavy or smooth finished floors, a cylindrical deck for grouted tile or small loose debris, and an orbital deck to strip floor finish without chemicals. FactoryCat sells all three: disk on every scrubber, cylindrical on six models, orbital on six. Orbital tops out at a 32-inch scrub path and is not offered on the two largest riders.

What is the difference between disk, cylindrical and orbital scrub decks?

A disk deck spins round, flat brushes or pad drivers against the floor. FactoryCat's disk deck uses a gimbaled mount, so the brush can tilt to follow an uneven floor.

A cylindrical deck uses tube-shaped brushes that turn at high speed. They scrub the floor and pick up small debris in the same pass.

An orbital deck holds a pad flat on a metal-backed pad holder. The pad does not spin like a disk. It moves in a tight, fast orbit.

The GTX rider takes all three decks. Its cylindrical brushes turn at 825 RPM, about three times the 270 RPM of its disk brushes. Its orbital deck runs on a 1 hp motor at 2,700 RPM. FactoryCat gives that as a motor rating, not a brush speed.

Which deck suits your floor type?

Pick disk for wavy floors, where the slab dips and rises. The gimbaled mount lets the brush tilt to follow the dips. Disk also covers flat, smooth, finished floors. Fit a pad holder and disposable pads instead of a brush.

Pick cylindrical for concrete, grouted tile and other flat, durable surfaces. FactoryCat lists tile and grout cleaning as a cylindrical strength, and indoor track fields as a good fit. If the dirt sits down in grout lines, this is your deck.

Pick orbital for VCT and other finished floors that you strip and recoat. FactoryCat lists VCT prep and recoat as an orbital benefit.

If your floors are mixed and loose debris is not a problem, start with disk. It is the only deck on every FactoryCat scrubber, and it takes brushes and pads. Its brush range also runs rougher: Super Grit, the roughest of the nine options on FactoryCat's brush and pad chart, comes only as a disk brush.

Do you still need to sweep before you scrub?

With a cylindrical deck, often not. FactoryCat builds it for floors that are "extremely dirty and have small debris that would otherwise require pre-sweeping". Its published benefits include "Eliminates Pre-Sweeping" and "Scrub & Sweep Simultaneously".

It is built for small debris. A heavy load of dry debris, or anything large, still needs a sweep or a pick-up by hand first.

With a disk or orbital deck, sweep or dust-mop first. Only the cylindrical deck is sold to pick up debris.

So look at what sits on the floor, not only at the floor itself. Small loose debris points to cylindrical. Six FactoryCat scrubbers take a cylindrical deck, with paths from 25 to 46 inches. A floor that is dirty but clear of debris leaves all three decks open, and the floor type decides.

Which deck strips floor finish without chemicals?

The orbital deck. It is the only FactoryCat deck sold for chemical-free stripping.

In FactoryCat's own words, the orbital deck's scrubbing power "makes it ideal for deep scrubbing and chemical free stripping. No floor stripper, reduces costs, eliminates unintended damage, and significantly reduces slip and fall risk."

FactoryCat also lists a "Reduction in Water Usage" as an orbital-deck benefit. Its newest brochure prints that bullet with no figure, so treat the size of the saving as unpublished.

The six orbital models are the MicroMini, Micro-HD, Mini-HD and Mag-HD walk-behinds, and the Pilot and GTX riders.

Which deck takes pads, and which takes brushes?

Disk takes both brushes and pads. Cylindrical takes brushes only. Orbital takes pads, on its metal-backed pad holder.

Disk runs pads through a pad driver. FactoryCat's chart lists nine brush and pad options, and four of them are disk-only, including both pad drivers. FactoryCat also lists "Lowest Maintenance Cost" as a disk-deck benefit.

Five of the nine options come as cylindrical brushes: nylon, tampico, and the Tough, Midi and Light grit brushes. There is no pad option for the cylindrical deck.

FactoryCat publishes no prices for pads or brushes. They are the part you keep replacing, so ask your dealer to price them for the deck you pick.

Which FactoryCat machines take all three decks?

Four do: the Micro-HD, Mini-HD and Mag-HD walk-behinds, and the GTX rider. Each model page lists its decks under Choose a Scrub System.

Scrub paths vary by deck. The Mag-HD, for example, takes a disk deck up to 34 inches, a 29 or 33-inch cylindrical deck, or a 28 or 32-inch orbital deck. The GTX covers 25 to 34 inches across its three decks.

Among the four, coverage runs from the Micro-HD, at up to 12,059 sq ft per hour, to the GTX, at up to 21,661 sq ft per hour. Both are practical figures, based on ISSA 2010 cleaning times. FactoryCat publishes one figure per machine, not one per deck.

Four more scrubbers take two decks each. The MicroMini walk-behind and the Pilot rider take disk or orbital, so neither offers the deck that sweeps while it scrubs. The GTR and the XR take disk or cylindrical, so neither offers orbital. The XR has the widest paths: a 45-inch disk deck or a 46-inch cylindrical deck. The Rebel stand-on takes one deck, a 20-inch disk.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Deck typeDiskCylindricalOrbital
Best floor typeWavy; smooth finished (pads)Concrete, grouted tileVCT you strip and recoat
Grout linesNot a listed strengthYes, a listed strengthNot a listed use
Loose debrisSweep firstPicks up small debris as it scrubsSweep first
Pads or brushesBoth, pads via a pad driverBrushes onlyPads on a metal-backed holder
Maintenance costLowestNot publishedNot published
Water useNot publishedNot publishedListed benefit; no figure
Chemical-free strippingNot listedNot listedYes
FactoryCat scrub paths17"–45"25"–46"20"–32"
Models offering itEvery scrubber6 models6 models

Micro-HD v2.1

Agile, quiet, and powerful, this compact industrial walk-behind floor scrubber is ready to take on smaller spaces with any floor type. Rubberized floors, grouted tile, exposed aggregate and concrete floors are no match. Select our SUDS on board soap dilution system to better control your cleaning chemical costs. Available in 20”(51cm) - 26”(66cm) scrub width.

Mini-HD v2.1

With the perfect balance of maneuverability and productivity, the Mini-HD v2 will simplify and improve your cleaning. This mid-sized industrial walk-behind floor scrubber offers battery pack options, available ZerO3 On-Demand Aqueous Ozone chemical free cleaning system, and selectable tires. This industrial grade floor scrubber can be customized to fulfill your needs. Available in 20”(51cm) - 29”(74cm) scrub width.

Mag-HD v2.2

For large areas not big enough for a ride-on floor scrubber, but where maximum output is required from an industrial grade walk behind floor scrubber, the Mag-HD v2 is the clear winner. Offering exceptional run time that allows you to scrub a long time on a single charge. Multiple scrub deck options generate high operator productivity. Include an optional Spray Jet spray wand to increase the cleaning capabilities beyond that of a typical scrubber. Available in 28”(71cm) - 34”(86cm) scrub width.

GTX v2.2

Navigation of your facility is easy with this compact ride on auto scrubber. Say, “so long” to the fatigued operator from walking behind a traditional auto scrubber. With this industrial ride on floor scrubber your staff will clean more square footage during their shift and still have the time and energy to do additional work. With impressive down pressure and brush speed this machine cleans your toughest dirt. Available in 26”(68cm) - 33”(84cm) scrub width.
Yes, an orbital scrub deck can strip floor finish with water and no stripper chemical, because its pad scrubs in small, fast orbits instead of spinning. FactoryCat offers an orbital deck on six scrubbers and lists a "Reduction in Water Usage" for it. The trade-off is time and pad wear, and very heavy build-up can still need a chemical strip, so test a small area first.
Use pads on smooth, finished floors such as sealed VCT, and brushes on textured, grouted, uneven or bare concrete floors, where bristles reach low spots. On a FactoryCat scrubber, the disk deck takes either, the orbital deck takes pads, and the cylindrical deck takes brushes only, in five of the nine options FactoryCat lists. Rougher grades clean harder but wear the finish and load the motor more.
For VCT, scrub daily with a red pad on a disk deck, and use an orbital deck for recoat prep or to strip finish with water and no stripper chemical. Six FactoryCat scrubbers offer that deck: a walk-behind for up to 31,568 sq ft in a 2-hour window at practical rates, the Pilot or GTX rider above that. Any pad rougher than red starts cutting finish.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an orbital scrub deck the same as an oscillating one?

Yes. Buyers use both words for a deck whose pad moves in a tight orbit instead of spinning. FactoryCat labels it orbital, and its own deck description uses both words for the same deck.

What PSI does each deck put on the floor?

FactoryCat publishes no PSI figure for any deck. It gives brush down pressure in pounds instead: from up to 100 lbs on the MicroMini to up to 250 lbs on the XR. Those figures are per machine, so they do not tell the three decks apart.

Can a cylindrical deck run pads?

No. FactoryCat's cylindrical decks take brushes only. For pads, choose a disk deck with a pad driver or an orbital deck.

Is a cylindrical deck the same as a sweeper-scrubber?

Not quite. A cylindrical deck picks up small debris as it scrubs, so a cylindrical machine is often called a sweeper-scrubber, and FactoryCat's own XR page calls the XR one. A machine with its own broom and hopper ahead of the scrub deck is a different design, and FactoryCat does not build one.

Which deck is best for VCT?

For stripping the finish before a recoat, the orbital deck: FactoryCat lists VCT prep and recoat as an orbital benefit. For routine scrubbing, a disk deck with a pad holder and pads also fits finished VCT.